Live Virtual Event: • 5 Days • 25 Sessions • $50,000 in Prizes
Join the most anticipated virtual event March 10–14 @ 1 PM ET
Register Now
Unlock your Prime Day potential! Month-by-month strategies inside.
Download the complete calendar and playbook for free
Free Download
Are you prepared for 2024 fees? Download our free Amazon Fee
Stack White Paper
for 2024 to protect your business.
Carbon 6
NEW! Download the free Amazon
Fee Stack White Paper
for 2024.
Free Download
Free Download
Take your Seller Central operations off your to-do listHire us for around-the-clock Amazon account management!
Learn More
ManageByStats is now FREE! Get this ultimate, all-in-one tool suite to boost your profit on Amazon.
Learn More
We double our reimbursements efforts
to get you 20% more back from Amazon!
Learn More
Urgent: Amazon sellers take action now!
Amazon reduced the reimbursement window by a staggering 88.89%, from 18 months to 60 days starting October 23, 2024.
Start Your Free Audit
3
MINUTE READ TIME
Published
November 11, 2022
|
Carbon6 Team

|
Amazon Seller News

Why Amazon’s New Reimbursement Policy Will Anger FBA Sellers

Why Amazon’s New Reimbursement Policy Will Anger FBA Sellers

Table of Contents

In the wake of the recent good news that it now allows Venmo transactions, Amazon just made another staggering reveal, this time to its reimbursement policy. Unlike the Venmo announcement, though, this one is certain to put FBA sellers in a very sour mood. 

The changes took effect as of November 11, 2022, but what are they and how will they really affect FBA businesses? 

30+ Speakers
Live Virtual Event: 5 Days • 25 Sessions • $50,000 in Prizes Join the virtual event March 10–14 @ 1 PM ET
Register Now
Take Seller Central operations off your to-do list
Trust our team of experts with 24/7 account management!
Learn More
NEW! Download the free Amazon Fee Stack White Paper for 2024.
Free Download
Unlock your Prime Day potential!
Download the complete playbook for free
Free Download
ManageByStats is now FREE!
Get the complete data suite to boost your profits.
Learn More
We double our reimbursements efforts to get you 20% more back
Learn More
NEW! Free Q4 Playbook to boost your Amazon sales! Your guide to peak-season success with key priorities and timelines.
Download Now

How Is Amazon’s New Reimbursement Policy Different?

Amazon’s reimbursement policy currently states:

“If an item you send to us as part of the Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) service is lost or damaged at a facility or by a carrier operated by Amazon or on behalf of Amazon, we will replace that item with a new item of the same FNSKU or we will reimburse you for it.”

This statement has not changed from the previous version of the policy; the main difference now is how much they will reimburse sellers. The new policy will reimburse sellers at a discounted rate for any unfillable items (damaged or lost items) that cannot be sold as “New.” 

Amazon currently uses several indicators to determine a reimbursement value:

  • Median price seller has sold that item on Amazon over the last 18 months 
  • Median price other sellers have sold that item on Amazon over the last 18 months 
  • Current list price for that item (or mean list price if multiple listings)
  • Current list price for the same item from other Amazon sellers

It is not yet clear where the discounted rate will come into play with these indicators, but it is worth keeping in mind that a shipment to Amazon or a fulfillment center operations claim will only reimburse the estimated proceeds of that item, aka the estimated sales price minus referral fees and fulfillment fees.

How Will Amazon’s Reimbursement Policy Affect FBA Sellers?

The new policy could drastically impact profit margins for FBA sellers, depending on how discounted the reimbursements are, and how many returns a seller receives. A reduction in profit will especially be felt in Q4 for sellers seeing higher sales and return volumes for the holiday period. 

Aside from the immediate effect of lost profits, a longer term adjustment may be made by FBA sellers to move to FBM to make up for increased prices and more FBA changes that take money out of sellers' pockets.

30+ Speakers
Live Virtual Event: 5 Days • 25 Sessions • $50,000 in Prizes Join the virtual event March 10–14 @ 1 PM ET
Register Now
NEW! Free Q4 Playbook to boost your Amazon sales for peak-season success.
Download Now
Unlock your Prime Day potential!

Download the playbook for free
Free Download
Take Seller Central operations off your to-do list
Trust our team of experts with 24/7 account management!
Learn More

What Can Amazon Sellers Do to Fulfill Reimbursements?

For now, the process of filing a claim for reimbursements is unchanged. The policy change goes into effect for eligible claims as of November 11. However, Amazon’s policy pages do not clarify if the discounted rate for reimbursements will be applicable to all claims submitted after that date, regardless of the date the item was lost. 

Presently, Amazon owes money to 99% of sellers. If you’re looking for a way to claim back what is owed to you by Amazon, Carbon6 tools like Seller Investigators can help. As experts in Amazon reimbursement claims, Seller Investigators helps you get paid by reviewing your FBA account to compile case reports and submit cases on your behalf.

Recent Newsletters

Top 5 Amazon Seller Reads this Week: Issue #216
Carbon6 Team
Feb 21, 2025
Newsletters
Top 5 Amazon Seller Reads this Week: Issue #216
Price increases loom as US-China tensions rise. Plus, Walmart's seller shift, Amazon kills Inspire, and why Buy with Prime adoption signals growth.
See Article
Top 5 Amazon Seller Reads this Week: Issue #215
Carbon6 Team
Feb 14, 2025
Newsletters
Top 5 Amazon Seller Reads this Week: Issue #215
Amazon testing DTC site traffic, TikTok launches subscription model, sellers hit 62% share, ad revenue reaches $17.3B, and Q-commerc debuts in India.
See Article
Insights: Carbon6 events season kicks off
Carbon6 Team
Feb 11, 2025
Newsletters
Insights: Carbon6 events season kicks off
The dust has settled on the arrival of 2025, and Q1 is well underway. Here at Carbon6, we’re gearing up for some of the biggest events of the year, with ASGTG, MDS Inspire, and Prosper Show all happening in March.
See Article

Recent Posts

Amazon ACOS & TACOS Benchmarks (Plus Strategies to Reduce Costs and Boost Sales)
David McDaniel
Feb 25, 2025
For Your Business
Amazon ACOS & TACOS Benchmarks (Plus Strategies to Reduce Costs and Boost Sales)
Key metrics for Amazon advertising, Amazon ACOS and TACOS, each have industry average benchmarks that can be greatly improved with the right strategy.
See Article
Amazon Seller Updates: Inspire Replaced, Order Handling Changes & Temu’s Trust Struggles
Chelsea Cohen
Feb 21, 2025
Amazon Seller News
Amazon Seller Updates: Inspire Replaced, Order Handling Changes & Temu’s Trust Struggles
Amazon vs. Temu trust battle, Inspire replaced by AI, and new order handling limits—get the latest Amazon seller updates and marketplace changes.
See Article
How to Improve Operational Efficiency for Amazon Sellers in 2025
Shannon Curley
Feb 20, 2025
For Your Business
How to Improve Operational Efficiency for Amazon Sellers in 2025
Actionable tips and tools to improve operational efficiency for Amazon sellers in 2025, minimizing losses and boosting client loyalty for agencies.
See Article